State of Fear

State of Fear

State of Fear
by Michael Crichton
Published by HarperCollinsPublishers in the U.K. in 2004
717 pages
ISBN 0007181604

Michael Crichton has been a master at creating real page-turners for decades. He brought us The Andromeda Strain and Jurassic Park, Rising Sun and the awesome Airframe, to name just a few. But when in the past he was focusing on delivering suspense-packed thrillers with a bit of opinion, he now has reversed this scheme: State of Fear is a lot of (Crichton’s) opinion with a wrapper of suspense. So, what is it all about?

The National Environmental Resource Fund (NERF) is an environmental organization that wants to make the world a better place. The problem du jour is climate change and global warming, caused by human CO2 emissions. In order to raise public awareness for this, NERF is preparing a lawsuit against the US government for polluting the air (which raises the sea levels, which will inevitably lead to the flooding of the small island state of Vanutu). They also engage in planning a big international conference on the topic. Now, NERF is run mostly by smart lawyers and clever marketers rather than researchers, a fact that comes handy when collecting money from sponsors like George Morton, a wealthy guy from Los Angeles. And NERF is quite successful. They just know which cards to play and how to address their target audience, the rich and the beautiful. And so, Morton is willing to give ten million dollars to NERF, for the good cause. That makes him NERF’s “Concerned Citizen of The Year”. Morton, however, discovers that the facts on global warming presented by NERF are not as simple and clear as he always thought, and that NERF is running a huge bill. When he complains to the head of NERF, Nick Drake, he just gets an angry response without any real explanations. And then Morton dies in a car accident. This leaves just Peter Evans, one of Mortons independent advisors, to dig out the truth about NERF and Morton’s death…

I’ll leave it at that as I do not want to spoil the story for those who are looking for a well crafted thriller. The story needs some time to build up (unusually long for Crichton), but then it becomes a Crichton-esque chase around the world: Paris, Tokyo, Vancouver, Los Angeles, Antarctica. Our hero gets to see the most remote places and brilliantly masters several deadly situations in order to solve the NERF puzzle. All the action is a bit forseeable, but still a page-turner; one simply has to know whether and how Evans can survive the trip to Antarctica, and so the pages just fly by. Crichton’s experience in writing exciting screenplays clearly shines through these action sequences. So, if you are looking for a good thriller, this book is it. But I have to warn you: State of Fear is certainly not Crichton’s masterpiece in this arena. Yes, people get murdered by mysterious killers using strange weapons. Yes, he takes you to exotic locations. Yes, it all comes together in the end. But with the big picture missing until the end, the focus is put on the individual scenes, and these are often just a bit too obvious, and for my taste simply not innovative enough. But then again, the book is still better than average compared to your typical thriller.

Which brings up the question: What else has Crichton in store for the us? Why should you read it? Well, the real dynamite lies in the environmental discussion. By using real facts and official statistics (e.g. from NASA’s GISS), Crichton drives home point after point, basically saying that the whole CO2 discussion appears to be a massive scam to keep the masses in a state of fear (hence the title of the book) and thus docile.

One example of how superbly Crichton does this: Evans, who is a strong believer in CO2 causing global warming at that time, visits the Vanutu lawsuit team to meet Drake. As he is still on the phone, the team is interviewing Evans to see how he reacts to facts that might be presented by the defendant. They start to ask nasty questions about global warming and present evidence to him, e.g. this chart showing the Global Temperature and CO2 levels from 1880 to 2003:

Global Temperature 1880-2003

Evans interprets the chart as follows: “World temperatures have been rising since about 1890, but they start to go up steeply around 1970, when industrialization is most intense, which is the real proof of global warming.” When asked, he explains that the rapid increase in temperature since 1970 is caused by “rising carbon dioxide levels from industrialization.” Then the interviewer brings his attention to the period from 1940 to 1970, and presents another chart, a close-up of that period:

Global Temperature vs. CO2 1940-1970

Then the interviewer wickedly asks: “So, if rising carbon dioxide is the cause of rising temperatures, why didn’t it cause temperatures to rise from 1940 to 1970?”, to which Evans can only answer: “I don’t know.”

And indeed, little do we know. Crichton fills that gap by presenting a wealth of information, the result of three years of researching this topic, and interestingly enough – way ahead of his time. The book was first published in 2004, long before the climate discussion among mainstream politicians started to take off. Crichton’s extensive bibliography provides excellent pointers for further reading, and in a closing note he actually explains what he really thinks about this whole issue.

But I recommend this book to you, even if you are not interested in environmental topics at all. This book might change some of the views on the CO2 issue (which are re-iterated relentlessly by the media) that you might have today. It will put a bright spotlight on the real reasons why politicians, scientists and environmental organizations around the world are jumping on the CO2 bandwagon right now.

Mind you, I am all for protecting the environment and using energy cautiously, but I am against those new restrictions, new taxes and new laws that the politicians may force upon us by claiming that it will protect us from global warming. They have discovered that global warming seems to be a perfect tool to keep the masses in check.

In his book, Crichton concludes that mankind can not change the climate anyway. One of the figures says towards the end:

Our planet is five billion years old, and it has been changing constantly all during that time. [...] Our atmosphere is as violent as the land beneath it. At any moment there are one thousand five hundred electrical storms across the planet. Eleven lightning bolts strike the ground each second. A tornado tears across the surface every six hours. And every four days, a giant cyclonic storm, hundreds of miles in diameter, spins over the ocean and wreaks havoc on the land.

The nasty little apes that call themselves human beings can do nothing except run and hide. For these same apes to imagine they can stabilize this atmosphere is arrogant beyond belief. They can’t control the climate.

The reality is, they run from the storms.

It’s an excellent book. Read it!

* * *

P.S.: A note for German readers. If you are capable of reading English, I strongly suggest to go for the original English version as the German translation (Welt in Angst, Blessing Verlag) seems to have completely lost it. Zoran Drvenkar points out that several important passages have been left out or not been translated correctly. Please read Drvenkar’s excellent German review on Amazon.de.

Comments are closed.